THE SHORT ANSWER
Both are credible Windows baselines in the cited lab period; switch only for a specific protection or workflow requirement you can explain.
- Consider it for
- Windows users evaluating a free third-party antivirus against built-in protection.
- Keep in mind
- Adding a second real-time antivirus is not the same as adding an extra layer safely.
Start with the protection already running
A Windows antivirus comparison should begin with the actual baseline. Microsoft's Windows Security documentation identifies Microsoft Defender Antivirus as a built-in component and explains how it changes state when another active antivirus is installed. [1]
This source-based comparison asks whether replacing that baseline solves a real need. We have not installed the two products side by side, measured their notifications or run malware samples. A switch can be reasonable, but it should be tied to a specific requirement rather than the assumption that a downloadable product must be better than an included one.
Compare the same laboratory period
AV-TEST's July–August 2026 Windows 11 reports record Avast Free Antivirus 26.6 at 6/6 for protection, performance and usability. Microsoft Defender Antivirus 4.18 received 6/6, 5.5/6 and 6/6 respectively. These are category scores from that lab, not AVHW ratings. [2] [3]
Our interpretation is that the cited period supports considering both as protection options. Avast has a higher performance category score there, but the report cannot tell you the precise difference on your particular machine. It also does not settle interface preference, the frequency of upgrade prompts or the value of separately paid applications.
What a switch should achieve
Write a sentence naming the improvement you want: a preferred management interface, a required control or a different support arrangement. Then verify it in the chosen product. If you cannot name the improvement, first check that the existing protection is enabled and updated before adding another decision to maintain.
Avast's current documentation distinguishes its new Avast One experience from the legacy bundle. That matters because an old paid-plan review may not describe the free application you would install today. [4] Use the exact current product rather than assuming all versions of the brand contain the same tools.
Do not evaluate by stacking engines
Microsoft's antivirus FAQ advises against running multiple real-time antivirus products together because they can affect performance. An on-demand scan used when requested is a different situation from two always-on engines inspecting the same activity. [5]
Follow the relevant vendor's transition instructions when changing products. After installation or removal, confirm which provider Windows Security reports as active. Microsoft's scanning guide identifies the protection-provider area as the place to check. [6] Do not leave the computer unprotected while trying to compare two subscriptions or free tools.
Free protection and paid extras are separate decisions
A strong free-antivirus laboratory result does not establish the value of a paid VPN, cleanup application or other upgrade. If an additional service interests you, evaluate its function, compatibility and recurring payment on its own merits.
Likewise, choosing the built-in baseline does not remove the need to manage updates, backups and account security. Our practical recommendation is to budget attention as well as money. A setup that someone understands and maintains may be more useful to them than a longer list of tools they cannot manage.
Verdict
We would not tell every Windows user to replace Defender, or every Avast user to uninstall it. The cited lab reports give both a reasonable place in the comparison. Decide whether the specific change improves your requirements, then keep one appropriate real-time antivirus active and verify its status.
Read the full Avast One review for package distinctions, or Microsoft Defender vs paid antivirus for the broader question of paying for a suite.
Sources & evidence
Sources were checked on 8 November 2026. Vendor documentation establishes published features; lab reports apply only to their named product, platform and test period. Recommendations are AVHW's interpretation.
- Microsoft Support: Windows Security app overviewChecked 2026-11-08
- AV-TEST: Avast Free Antivirus 26.6, Windows 11, July–August 2026Checked 2026-11-08
- AV-TEST: Microsoft Defender 4.18, Windows 11, July–August 2026Checked 2026-11-08
- Avast Support: new Avast One FAQChecked 2026-11-08
- Microsoft Support: antivirus and antimalware FAQChecked 2026-11-08
- Microsoft Support: scan an item with Windows SecurityChecked 2026-11-08